do i need a protein skimmer on nano

[labby]

I've got a 10 gallon nano reef, just started cycling. Do I really need a protein skimmer or can I get by with water changes? Heard mixed things, some say it's overkill for small tanks.

[zenox_5]

Depends on your bioload. If you're keeping it light with just a couple small fish and some corals, water changes might cut it. But if you're gonna add more, a skimmer could help keep things stable.

[trailblaz0r]

Protein skimmers are worth it even in nanos. They pull out dissolved organics before they break down, which means less work for your biological filter. I run one on my 15 gallon and it's been a game changer for water clarity.

[krakena_9]

I skipped the skimmer on my 5 gallon and just do weekly water changes. So far so good, but I only have a clownfish and a few soft corals. Might be different if you're planning more.

[apricot]

Protein skimmers are worth it even in nanos. They pull out dissolved organics before they break down, which means less work for your biological filter. I run one on my 15 gallon and it's been a game changer for water clarity.

I agree with this. Even in small tanks, a skimmer can reduce the frequency of water changes and keep parameters more stable. It's an investment but pays off long-term.

[dervin]

I don't use one in my 10 gallon. Just do 20% water changes every week and my params stay solid. Skimmers seem like extra hassle for such a small volume.

[labby]

Thanks for the input, everyone. I think I'll hold off for now and see how the tank does with just water changes. If I start having issues, I'll reconsider.

[zenox_5]

Thanks for the input, everyone. I think I'll hold off for now and see how the tank does with just water changes. If I start having issues, I'll reconsider.

Smart move. Start simple and adjust as needed. That's how I've always done it.

[trailblaz0r]

Just keep an eye on your nitrates. If they start creeping up, that's when a skimmer might be worth adding. Better to catch it early than deal with algae blooms later.

[apricot]

Also, consider your feeding habits. If you're heavy-handed with food, a skimmer can help offset that. But if you're careful, water changes might be enough.