keeping cichlids in a real-time strategy setting

[DeepDiver]

I've got a 35 gallon tank set up with lots of little caves and rock structures - it's perfect for hiding spots. I've always wanted to add some African Cichlids, probably around 5 or 6 since that's the recommended amount for my tank size. But I also want to mix it up with some other species to add more life to the tank. I'm thinking maybe some RTS or a Rainbow Shark, but I know they can get pretty big. What do you think - can I make it work with the Cichlids or should I pick one or the other?

[boomer]

Welcome to TFF.

Rift lake cichlids are quite particular about their environment. They require hard water, which can be a challenge in itself. Additionally, they tend to be quite aggressive, which further limits your options for tankmates. In a 35-gallon tank, you'll need to be very selective about the species and numbers you keep.

The RTS, on the other hand, is a cyprinid that thrives in soft water. While it may tolerate moderately hard water, it won't truly flourish. Its needs are too different from those of the rift lake fish, and it also has its own behavioral issues. The Rainbow Shark can be less aggressive, but it's still not a good match for rift lake fish.

In general, it's best to keep rift lake fish on their own, with only other fish from the same lake. Even then, you'll need to choose their tankmates carefully.

[DeepDiver]

Welcome to TFF.

Rift lake cichlids are quite particular about their environment. They require hard water, which can be a challenge in itself. Additionally, they tend to be quite aggressive, which further limits your options for tankmates. In a 35-gallon tank, you'll need to be very selective about the species and numbers you keep.

The RTS, on the other hand, is a cyprinid that thrives in soft water. While it may tolerate moderately hard water, it won't truly flourish. Its needs are too different from those of the rift lake fish, and it also has its own behavioral issues. The Rainbow Shark can be less aggressive, but it's still not a good match for rift lake fish.

In general, it's best to keep rift lake fish on their own, with only other fish from the same lake. Even then, you'll need to choose their tankmates carefully.

I'm guessing that also rules out Plecos living with Peacock cichlids, right?

[boomer]

I've got a 35 gallon tank set up with lots of little caves and rock structures - it's perfect for hiding spots. I've always wanted to add some African Cichlids, probably around 5 or 6 since that's the recommended amount for my tank size. But I also want to mix it up with some other species to add more life to the tank. I'm thinking maybe some RTS or a Rainbow Shark, but I know they can get pretty big. What do you think - can I make it work with the Cichlids or should I pick one or the other?

It really isn't advisable to keep Plecos and Peacock cichlids together. The requirements for water parameters, habitat, and their respective behaviors are just too disparate. To ensure the well-being of both species, it's best to keep them separate.

While it's technically possible to house them in the same tank, it would be a compromise that would likely cause one or both to suffer. There's no middle ground that would truly provide both with the optimal conditions for a healthy life, and that's where the issue becomes a matter of humane treatment.